| Tahun | Pemenang | Nominasi lainnya | Catatan |
| 2008 | Gaku: Minna no Yama, karya Shinichi Ishizuka[2] | - Yotsuba&!, karya Kiyohiko Azuma (peringkat kedua)
- Umimachi Diary 1: Semishigure no Yamugoro, karya Akimi Yoshida (peringkat ketiga)
- Ōoku: The Inner Chambers, karya Fumi Yoshinaga
- Kinō Nani Tabeta?, karya Fumi Yoshinaga
- Kimi ni Todoke, karya Karuho Shiina
- Imperial Guards (ja), karya Daisuke Satō dan Yū Itō
- Tomehane! Suzuri Kōkō Shodōbu, karya Katsutoshi Kawai
- Natsume's Book of Friends, karya Yuki Midorikawa
- Himawari: Kenichi Legend, karya Akiko Higashimura
- Flower of Life, karya Fumi Yoshinaga
- Moyasimon: Tales of Agriculture, karya Masayuki Ishikawa
| Pada edisi pertama dari acara ini, dua belas manga masuk nominasi.[1] |
| 2009 | Chihayafuru, karya Yuki Suetsugu[3] | - Space Brothers, karya Chūya Koyama
- March Comes in Like a Lion, karya Chika Umino
- Shinya Shokudō, karya Yarō Abe
- Seishun Shōnen Magazine 1978-1983, karya Makoto Kobayashi
- Saint Young Men, karya Hikaru Nakamura
- Tomehane! Suzuri Kōkō Shodōbu, karya Katsutoshi Kawai
- Toriko, karya Mitsutoshi Shimabukuro
- Mama wa Tenparist, karya Akiko Higashimura
- Yondemasuyo, Azazel-san, karya Kubo Yasuhisa
| Pada edisi kedua, sepuluh manga masuk nominasi.[4] |
| 2010 | Thermae Romae, karya Mari Yamazaki[5] | - I Am a Hero, karya Kengo Hanazawa
- Aoi Honoo, karya Kazuhiko Shimamoto
- Space Brothers, karya Chūya Koyama
- Otoko no Isshō, karya Keiko Nishi
- Princess Jellyfish, karya Akiko Higashimura
- Kōkō Kyūji Zawa-san, karya Eriko Mishima
- Bakuman, karya Tsugumi Ohba dan Takeshi Obata
- Mushi to Uta: Ichikawa Haruko Sakuhin-Shū, karya Haruko Ichikawa
- Moteki, karya Mitsurou Kubo
| Pada edisi ketiga, sepuluh manga masuk nominasi.[6] |
| 2011 | March Comes in Like a Lion, karya Chika Umino[7] | - I Am a Hero, karya Kengo Hanazawa
- A Bride's Story, karya Kaoru Mori
- Omo ni Naitemasu, karya Akiko Higashimura
- Kokkoku, karya Seita Horio
- Sayonara mo Iwazu ni, karya Kentarō Ueno
- Saru, karya Daisuke Igarashi
- Shitsuren Shokoratie, karya Setona Mizushiro
- Shingeki no Kyojin, karya Hajime Isayama
- Drifters, karya Kouta Hirano
- Don't Cry Girl, karya Tomoko Yamashita
- Hana no Zubora-Meshi, karya Masayuki Kusumi dan Etsuko Mizusawa
- Mashiro no Oto, karya Marimo Ragawa
| Pada edisi keempat, tiga belas manga masuk nominasi.[8] |
| 2012 | Silver Spoon, karya Hiromu Arakawa[9] | - I Am a Hero, karya Kengo Hanazawa
- The Flowers of Evil, karya Shūzō Oshimi
- Gurazeni, karya Yūji Moritaka dan Keiji Adachi
- Getenrou, karya Masakazu Ishiguro
- Your Lie in April, karya Naoshi Arakawa
- Shōwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjū, karya Haruko Kumota
- Giga Tokyo Toy Box, karya Ume
- Takasugi-san-chi no O-Bentou, karya Nozomi Yanahara
- Tonari no Seki-kun, karya Takuma Morishige
- Drifters, karya Kouta Hirano
- 25-ji no Bakansu, karya Haruko Ichikawa
- Nobunaga Concerto, karya Ayumi Ishii
- Hibi Rock, karya Katsumasa Enokiya
- Hōzuki no Reitetsu, karya Natsumi Eguchi
| Pada edisi kelima, lima belas manga masuk nominasi.[10] |
| 2013 | Umimachi Diary, karya Akimi Yoshida[11] | - Ansatsu Kyōshitsu, karya Yusei Matsui
- Welcome to the Ballroom, karya Tomo Takeuchi
- Bokura no Funka-sai, karya Keigo Shinzō
- A Bride's Story, karya Kaoru Mori
- Hi Score Girl, karya Rensuke Oshikiri
- Kui Ryōko Sakuhin-shū: Seven Little Sons of the Dragon, karya Ryōko Kui
- Ningen Karimen-chū, karya Taeko Uzugi
- Ore Monogatari!!, karya Kazune Kawahara dan Aruko
- Sanzoku Diary, karya Kentarō Okamoto
- Terra Formars, karya Yū Sasuga dan Kenichi Tachibana
| Pada edisi keenam, sebelas manga masuk nominasi.[12] |
| 2014 | A Bride's Story, karya Kaoru Mori | - Ashizuri Suizokukan, karya panpanya
- Ajin, karya Gamon Sakurai
- Sakamoto desu ga?, karya Nami Sano
- Sayonara, Tama-chan, karya Kazuyoshi Takeda
- Jūhan Shuttai!, karya Naoko Matsuda
- The Seven Deadly Sins, karya Nakaba Suzuki
- Hikidashi ni Terrarium, karya Ryōko Kui
- Erased, karya Kei Sanbe
- One-Punch Man, karya One dan Yusuke Murata
| Pada edisi ketujuh, sepuluh manga masuk nominasi.[13] |
| 2015 | Blank Canvas: My So-Called Artist's Journey, karya Akiko Higashimura[14] | - Innocent, karya Shin'ichi Sakamoto
- Ōsama-tachi no Viking, karya Sadayasu dan Makoto Fukami
- Kasane, karya Daruma Matsuura
- Monthly Girls' Nozaki-kun, karya Izumi Tsubaki
- A Silent Voice, karya Yoshitoki Ōima
- Kodomo wa Wakatte Agenai, karya Rettou Tajima
- Dimitri Tomkins, karya Fumiko Takano
- Blue Giant, karya Shinichi Ishizuka
- Land of the Lustrous, karya Haruko Ichikawa
- Welcome to the Ballroom, karya Tomo Takeuchi
- Erased, karya Kei Sanbe
- My Hero Academia, karya Kōhei Horikoshi
- The Ancient Magus' Bride, karya Kore Yamazaki
| Pada edisi kedelapan, empat belas manga masuk nominasi.[15] |
| 2016 | Golden Kamuy, karya Satoru Noda[16] | - Okazaki ni Sasagu, karya Saho Yamamoto
- Koi wa Ameagari no You ni, karya Jun Mayuzuki
- Delicious in Dungeon, karya Ryōko Kui
- Tokyo Tarareba Musume, karya Akiko Higashimura
- Tonkatsu DJ Agetarō, karya Ipyao dan Yūjirō Koyama
- Nami yo Kiite Kure, karya Hiroaki Samura
- Hyakumanjō Labyrinth, karya Takamichi
- Blue Giant, karya Shinichi Ishizuka
- Erased, karya Kei Sanbe
- Machida-kun no Sekai, karya Yuki Andō
| Pada edisi kesembilan, sebelas manga masuk nominasi.[17] |
| 2017 | Hibiki: Shōsetsuka ni Naru Hōhō, karya Mitsuharu Yanamoto[18] | - Aoashi, karya Yūgo Kobayashi dan Naohiko Ueno
- Karakai Jōzu no Takagi-san, karya Sōichirō Yamamoto
- Kin no Kuni Mizu no Kuni, karya Nao Iwamoto
- Kūtei Dragons, karya Taku Kuwabara
- Golden Gold, karya Seita Horio
- Delicious in Dungeon, karya Ryōko Kui
- Tokyo Tarareba Musume, karya Akiko Higashimura
- Nami yo Kiite Kure, karya Hiroaki Samura
- High Score Girl, karya Rensuke Oshikiri
- Fire Punch, karya Tatsuki Fujimoto
- The Promised Neverland, karya Kaiu Shirai dan Posuka Demizu
- Watashi no Shōnen, karya Hitomi Takano
| Pada edisi kesepuluh, tiga belas manga masuk nominasi.[19] |
